top of page

"Leave it with me": The danger of being too helpful

Nov 5
5 min read
monkeys on your back

How a helpful phrase leads to overload and accidental resignation.


I’ve always tried to be a helpful person (I blame my parents). But over time, I’ve realised that 'helping' usually just means taking ownership of someone else's problem. I now think of these things as 'monkeys'. And all they do is pile on the extra workload and stress.


Now I'm sure you're wondering why I refer to it as a monkey. I first came across this metaphor many years ago, and I've returned to it throughout my career, usually at the exact moment I realised I was drowning in work.

Here's a simple example that may sound familiar.


You're in a meeting with your team. Someone raises a problem, and you say something simple and harmless: "Leave it with me. I'll think about it and get back to you."


What just happened?


Your colleague's workload just went down. Yours just went up. And you've given them a perfectly good reason to put down tools and wait for you. It's now your problem.


I've done this more times than I'd like to admit. My workload already seemed to have me working longer hours than anyone else in the team, and now I had another piece of work. Worse, when my colleague's boss asked how he was getting on, he'd point at me. Not a good place to be.


And when you're overloaded, it's remarkably easy to lose it over something small. Well done, I thought to myself. Another way to resign.


Where does the monkey idea come from?

In 1974, William Oncken Jr and Donald L. Wass wrote Management Time: Who's Got the Monkey? for Harvard Business Review. It was reissued as an HBR Classic in 1999 with a commentary by Stephen Covey, and it's still taught today. Ken Blanchard later turned the idea into a short book with Oncken and Hal Burrows, The One Minute Manager Meets the Monkey, which is where I first met it.


The idea is simple. A monkey isn't the problem itself. It's the next move. Whoever has the next move has the monkey. When a colleague brings you a problem and you say, "Let me think about it," the next move is yours. The monkey has jumped onto your back.


Oncken and Wass were writing about managers and their teams, and they called the result "subordinate-imposed time". In my experience, though, monkeys aren't fussy about hierarchy. In a matrix organisation (and my area of product management is about as matrixed as it gets) they can jump sideways from peers and other teams just as happily.


Remember - Helpful is good. Helpful and overloaded is how good people say things they can't take back.


Why it's a resignation trap

No single monkey is the problem. Each one is small, reasonable and well meant. The trouble is what they do together. They eat the time you'd planned for your own priorities, so you work later to catch up. Resentment builds, and then something trivial tips you over: a sharp reply sent at 11pm, a "fine, or I'll do it myself" in a meeting.


There's a less visible version too. You become the bottleneck. Your own deadlines slip, and at review time you're the one who missed them, while the person whose monkey it was looks perfectly on track.


The four rules, in plain English

In The One Minute Manager Meets the Monkey, Oncken's approach is boiled down to four rules:

  1. Describe it. Don't end the conversation until the next move is clear.

  2. Own it. Every monkey has one named owner at the lowest level that can look after it properly.

  3. Insure it. Agree how much freedom the owner has: recommend, then act, or act, then advise.

  4. Check it. Set a date to review progress. A monkey with no check-up either starves or finds its way back to you.


SAFE in action: the "let me think about it" moment

Let's go back to that meeting and run it through my SAFE Method. Four questions to ask before the monkey jumps:


Four questions to ask before the monkey jumps

Situation

Here's what was really going on in that meeting. My colleague owned the work stream, so the problem was his to solve. I just happened to be the person in the room who seemed to know the answer, and he pounced on it. With one sentence from him and my "let me think about it" response, the monkey jumped across the table, and the next move became mine.


On its own, that's one small monkey. But it wasn't on its own:

  • It was his monkey, and now it was on my back.

  • My diary was already full, so something of my own would have to slip.

  • He now had a ready answer for his boss: "I'm waiting on Tony."

  • And I was tired enough that the next small irritation could turn into something I'd regret.


That last one is the real danger. It's the Resignation Trap. Accumulated monkeys lead to cumulative overload, and overload leads to words said or written under pressure. Those words get remembered, repeated, and sometimes taken literally, as rudeness or worse, a resignation.


So the question became: how do I help without taking the next move?


Alternatives

I have four options:

  • Take it away. It's quick and kind, and the monkey moves to you.

  • Solve it on the spot. That's OK if it only takes two minutes. Oncken calls that shooting the monkey.

  • Hand it back with a clear next move and a date to check in.

  • Raise your workload with your own manager if the monkeys keep coming.


Most of the time, the third option is the right one. You still help. You just don't take the next move.


Firm Words

Keep them short, friendly and blame free.


In the meeting, use:"Good question. Rather than me going away with it, what would you recommend? Pull together a couple of options, and we'll pick one together on Thursday."


When it arrives sideways from a peer, use:"Happy to help you think it through, but it needs to stay with you. What's your next step, and when would you like me to look at it?"


When they keep coming, say to your manager:"I've picked up several pieces of work this month that belong with other teams. I'd like to hand them back properly. Can you back me on that?"


Evidence

Always follow up in writing the same day, one line per monkey: owner, next move, check-up date. It takes two minutes and does two jobs. It keeps the monkey on the right back, and when someone's boss asks who's holding things up, the answer is already in writing.


Over a few weeks, a simple log of the monkeys that came your way turns "I'm drowning" into "seven requests from three teams in a month". Its hard for your manager to act on a feeling. They can act on facts.


Practical tips: monkey-spotting phrases

Listen out for these. They sound helpful, but they are actually the sound of a monkey in flight.

  • "Leave it with me."

  • "Let me think about it and get back to you."

  • "Send me an email and I'll take a look."

  • "I'll have a word with them."


The fix: end every problem conversation with three answers. Who owns it? What's the next move? When do we check in?


The bottom line

Being helpful isn't the problem. Taking the next move is. Next time you hear yourself say "leave it with me", pause and ask who should really have the next move. Your colleague gets to grow, you keep your evenings, and you stay calm enough not to say the thing you'd regret.


Further reading:

Oncken, W. Jr. & Wass, D. L., "Management Time: Who's Got the Monkey?"

Harvard Business Review, Nov–Dec 1974 (HBR Classic reissue, 1999)

Blanchard, K., Oncken, W. Jr. & Burrows, H., The One Minute Manager Meets the Monkey, 1989

Comments


bottom of page